Holiday Recipe: OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust

This holiday recipe post, featuring an OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All stories, photos, and opinions are my own. #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias

With all the holiday parties coming up right now, I thought I would share a favorite holiday recipe of mine. It’s my husband’s cheesecake recipe, but today he’s made an OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust. It’s so easy and everyone will love you…I mean, it!

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias [ad]

I work in an office where we love to eat. I mean, what office full of women doesn’t love to eat? We look forward to the holidays just so we can all get together and eat a meal. We like to do pot luck with a theme from time to time, but we all have different expertise so sometimes we just go with what we know. I don’t know how to do much so I always delegate my cooking to Howard. He loves to cook for others because he says it makes his heart smile when others enjoy his food. So, this year, at my Christmas party, he decided to make this OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust and I just know it’s going to be a hit.

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias [ad]

Aren’t the holidays just the perfect time to get together and enjoy each other’s cooking? It seems like it was just time for Thanksgiving and now it’s time for a Christmas party. For Thanksgiving, we did a mexican theme, and Howard decided to make turkey enchiladas. They were such a hit that my office requested a “Howard holiday recipe” for this party as well. That’s all good with me because I’m not great at cooking so he decided that cheesecake was the way to go.

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias [ad]

Howard’s cheesecake recipe is so easy and he can add almost any flavor that anyone wants to it and he can make a regular cheesecake and top it with anything as well. I got to pick the flavor for this year’s cheesecake so I picked OREO and Nutter Butter cookies just to see if he could pull it off. I mean, who doesn’t love cookies and creme and peanut butter?

OREO cookies at Kroger

OREO cookies are a timeless treat that go well with any holiday celebration. I like to pick my OREO and Nutter Butter cookies up at Kroger because I can find all the OREO cookie varieties for the holidays. Plus, my stepmom has worked there for like 20 something years and Howard worked there for two years recently until he had his health problems and had to leave. Kroger is our choice for seasonal and everyday shopping in our little town where there’s only two grocery stores and a big retail/grocery store. Kroger has what we need and we’re in and out in a flash.

Now, I mentioned that Howard’s cheesecake recipe is super easy so let me give you the recipe and you can let me know what you think. I hope you find it to be easy as well.

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias [ad]

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust

What you’ll need:

1 package OREO cookies

1 package Nutter Butter cookies

5-8oz packages cream cheese

8 oz sour cream

1 cup sugar

3 tbsp melted butter

1 tsp vanilla extract

1/2 tsp lemon juice

1/4 cup flour

4 large eggs

What you’ll do:

For the crust, grind up the package of Nutter Butter cookies to a fine consistency. Add melted butter and mix. Press into bottom of 9 inch spring-form pan and about 1 inch up the side. Bake for 10 minutes on 325°.

For the cheesecake, grind OREO cookies to a coarse consistency and set aside. Blend remaining ingredients except flour and eggs until smooth. Add flour and mix until incorporated. Add one egg at a time and mix. Fold in OREO cookie crumbs slowly. Pour into crust and bake for 1 hour 10 minutes on 325°.

What do you think? Doesn’t that sound easy? Plus…OREO cookies!

OREO Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust #SpreadOREOCheer #CollectiveBias [ad]

What is your favorite flavor of cheesecake? What is your go to holiday recipe?


  1. Oh yum! Oreos and Nutter Butters in the same dessert. How perfect!
    karissa recently posted..Motivational Monday Linkup #57My Profile

  2. This is a dream come true for me! I’m such a chocolate addict!
    Katarina recently posted..December Book Releases – Children’s, FantasyMy Profile

  3. It is crazy to think how crazy my hubby and son would be for this recipe. Thanks for sharing because I love the take on the crust. Delish!

  4. I like the way the Oreo cookies and whipped cream are decorating the top of the cheesecake. I am also a fan of Nutter Butters.
    Yona Williams recently posted..Company Highlight: ModernTribe + GiveawayMy Profile

  5. Rebecca Swenor says:

    This is indeed an awesome recipe for Oreo Cheesecake with Nutter Butter Crust. I would have never thought to use Nutter Butter cookies for the crust but it does sound delicious and I will have to try this recipe.

  6. I love cheesecake! A combination of OREOs and Nutter Butters sound amazing! Thanks for sharing!

  7. Stacey says:

    I am a huge Nutter Butter fan! I do not know why I have never thought about using them for a crust before. Brilliant! I use OREOs for crust all the time. Such a great way to mix it up. In fact I am headed to Walmart to get cheesecake fixins today to make my step-son his birthday cheesecake. You bet OREOs are part of the recipe!
    Stacey recently posted..Holiday Dinner Party Menu for Eight for Under $100My Profile

  8. Now that is what I need right now, a pice of something good! Love the look of this!
    Chubskulit Rose recently posted..Visiting FamilyMy Profile

  9. Oh, to eat an Oreo or a Nutter Butter! Both are delicious, so I can’t imagine how tasty the combination will be.
    Tami @ This Mom’s Delight recently posted..Literacy Musing Mondays Linkup: AdventMy Profile

  10. I’ve never had cheesecake before. But this looks really good. I’m a huge oreo fan. I don’t think we have nutter butters in Canada so I’d be interested to try this!
    Jeanine recently posted..Winter Essentials for Him Gift Basket Tutorial #PowerYourHoliday #CollectiveBiasMy Profile

  11. CourtneyLynne says:

    Omg!!!! If this isn’t good porn I don’t know what is! I so need this pie in my life.

  12. Jen K says:

    This looks amazing. I have not had a cheesecake in so long. Thanks for sharing!
    Jen K recently posted..The Gift of Netflix – GiveawayMy Profile

  13. lisa says:

    This sounds like the best pie. I love Oreos and Nutter Butters so this would be my favorite pie!
    lisa recently posted..A Chevy Trax, My Family, and A Toy Donation #ChevyShopsforGoodMy Profile

  14. Wow this looks like a good one. Combining all of my favorite things and I know my daughter would freak out if I made this one for her!
    Melissa recently posted..Minions DIY Christmas OrnamentsMy Profile

  15. That would be gone in my house! What a delicious looking cheesecake, I love the nutter butter crust idea.
    ashleigh recently posted..Grandma’s Deluxe PotatoesMy Profile

  16. This looks SO DIVINE!! I am always on the hunt for a new OREO dessert to try, and I am such a sucker for cheesecake!! I am dying to try this recipe now!

  17. This looks so delicious and easy to make. I will have to get the supplies i need to make this on the weekend.

  18. ricci says:

    Oreo Chesecake?? This looks amazing!!! I need to try this for real!!!
    ricci recently posted..10 Things I Would Get at McDonalds with an Arch CardMy Profile

  19. Tonya C says:

    My kids are going to go crazy when I say we are making this for dessert and are actually going to be able to devour it right after! lol Cant wait to make and eat it!

  20. Paula says:

    This looks freaking delicious – and like such a fun and easy recipe. I love love love peanut butter.

  21. I’ve got to make these cheesecake! I am a big fan of Oreo and would love to try these.

  22. Blythe A. says:

    This recipe makes it very hard to stick to my clean eating program. There is nothing like adding Oreos to cheesecake.

  23. Oh my, the cheesecake looks amazing! I am craving for a slice right now.
    OurFamilyWorld recently posted..7 Sparkly Pregnancy Announcements To Start New Year’s EveMy Profile

  24. Debra says:

    Oreos AND Nutter Butters?! Wow! That sounds absolutely incredible. I am going to have to try it!
    Debra recently posted..Ravioli LasagnaMy Profile

  25. Nutter butter crust?!? That might be the best thing EVER!! I will definitely need to try this soon. I might top it with nutter butters instead of Oreos though 🙂
    April Mims recently posted..Pumpkin Spice Sugar Scrub and a Cup of RelaxationMy Profile

  26. tp keane says:

    ARE YOU KIDDING ME??? My kids better not see this or I’ll be making it for the rest of the year lol. Thanks for sharing… I might keep it on the down-low for the moment.

  27. Who doesn’t love an OREO? What a fabulous idea for a cheesecake!
    Michelle @ Sunshine and recently posted..How to Show Appreciation with Thoughtful Simple GiftsMy Profile

  28. I’m loving this dessert! You included two of my boyfriend’s favorite treats too. He’d love it if I made this!
    Liz Mays recently posted..Dating While Weird: Treat YoselfMy Profile

  29. I basically love anything with oreos in it! They are amazing! This cheesecake looks outrageously delicious!
    Logan Can recently posted..Kid Friendly Minion Craft + Movie NightMy Profile

  30. Abby asked me today if I’d make her a cheesecake so your post came at the perfect timing. I can’t wait to make this for her and maybe the other kids will like it as well since it has a different spin on it.
    Terri Ramsey Beavers recently posted..Why I’m Passionate about Passion House Coffee #DiscoverYourGenreMy Profile

  31. This cheesecake looks so stunning and delicious! It looks like you bought it from the Cheesecake Factory!

  32. Can you please just drop this off at my house? Yum, I mean seriously, yum! I love all kinds of cheesecake, but my favorite is probably the classic with strawberries. Oh man, I’m definitely going to have to make that soon 🙂
    Heather recently posted..How to Enjoy Family and Slow Down during a Busy SeasonMy Profile

  33. Jenna Wood says:

    I’ve had OREO cheesecake before but never with a Nutter Butter crust, you are a genius! Thanks for sharing this delicious OREO recipe! #client

  34. Your cheesecake looks really good. I love making special treats this time of year as well. So much fun!
    Sicorra@NotNowMomsBusy recently posted..How To Make This Christmas UnforgettableMy Profile

  35. This looks sooo good! Makes me so sad that I’m gluten-free!
    Esther @ The Cuteness recently posted..My Favorite Instagram Finds of 2015My Profile

  36. Om nom nom nom! Cheesecake is my one true weakness, so making an oreo cheesecake with nutter butter crust is my cryptonite.
    Jennifer recently posted..Indulge this Holiday Season with Folgers Gourmet Selections #FolgersGourmetHolidayMy Profile

  37. I am pretty sure my entire family would devour this the second I make it. Good idea for the holidays!
    Jeanette recently posted..Snickerdoodle Cinnamon Roll MuffinsMy Profile

  38. Everything about this is fantastic! Oreos. Nutter butter. Cheesecake. I’m in nom nom Heaven right now.
    Stacie @ Divine Lifestyle recently posted..Perfect Pairings with BROOKSIDE Chocolates and Clos du Bois {GIVEAWAY} #TalkAboutDeliciousMy Profile

  39. This is quite literally a food porn moment. I am salivating at the prospect of devouring this delicious cheesecake and especially since it has Oreo’s
    Ana De- Jesus recently posted..The 60’s Mini SkirtMy Profile

  40. Robin Rue (@massholemommy) says:

    Oh. My. GAWD! I could literally sit down and devour this entire thing in one sitting. It sounds SOOOO good.

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge